Should you stop giving Christmas gifts to people who don't give one back?

Should gifts always be reciprocated?

As the saying goes, giving is more important than receiving, but it's also nice to know the gesture goes both ways.

When you're consistently giving someone a Christmas present but never receiving one in return, however, you may start to wonder whether it's okay to stop.

Rita Linda Dayrit, a certified image consultant and founder of RLDD Manners and Mindfulness Training Center, said that your decision "depends on why you are giving a person Christmas presents."

"If you give someone a gift because that person has helped you in the past, then you should really not expect to receive a gift from that person," she said.

"But if all things are equal and in a way you value the relationship, then you might want to reduce the monetary value of your gift. So that it does not become so much of a burden to you," she added.

For instance, giving them a Christmas card would be enough. You may also choose to donate to charity in that person's name.

"You may want to examine your emotions, too. If you feel short-changed, then by all means stop giving," Dayrit said.

For modern etiquette coach Tracy Que, however, gift-giving should ultimately come without expectations.

"[Gift-giving] is, first and foremost, a thoughtful gesture—something given sincerely and wholeheartedly, without expecting anything in return," she said.

Que noted that this is particularly relevant in Filipino culture, where gifts often reflect affection, gratitude, and consideration for others.

"If someone is unable to give something in return, that is perfectly all right, because the true meaning of a gift lies in the sincerity of the gesture and the thought behind it," she said.

What if you didn't prepare a gift?

If the tables have turned and it's you who receives a present while standing there empty-handed, don't panic, as it's not too late to reciprocate the gesture.

"The Philippines has a long Christmas season. We can give gifts until the second week of January. So go ahead and send a gift. Then make sure they are on your list next year and send them the gift early," Dayrit said.

Que likewise stressed that there is no need to let the situation become awkward or rush to find something to give immediately.

"If someone gives me a gift and I have nothing prepared for them, I would simply receive it graciously and thank them sincerely, without allowing the moment to become awkward or making excuses for not having something to give in return," she said.

If you genuinely want to reciprocate, she said it can be done thoughtfully in the following days instead of rushing to match the gesture on the spot.

"My gift would feel sincere and intentional rather than something given merely out of obligation," she added.

Does the price tag matter? 

It's easy to get caught up in comparing price tags during the holidays, especially when someone gives you a gift that seems far more expensive than the one you prepared.

According to Dayrit, it's best not to fuss over it too much, as it's important to spend within your means.

"Get creative. Gifting is not about monetary values. It is really letting the other person know that you value them," she said.

Que shared the same sentiment in that it is not necessary to match the monetary value of a gift we receive.

"Even the simplest gift can carry great meaning when it is chosen and given from the heart with sincerity, affection, and genuine thoughtfulness," she highlighted.

For her, a Christmas present is ultimately a way of telling someone, "I thought of you."

When the gift isn't quite your taste

Receiving a gift is a wonderful feeling, until you find out that what's inside isn't really something on your wishlist. For some, it can be difficult to hide their disappointment, which puts them at risk of hurting the giver's feelings.

Dayrit stressed that you should take control of your responses.

"Smile and say thank you. It is rude to say that you don’t particularly like what they have prepared for you," she said.

Fortunately, the gift-giving culture in the Philippines gives you a little more room to manage your reaction.

"In the Philippines, unlike in the US where it is good etiquette to open a gift in front of the giver, we are not expected to do the same," Dayrit noted.

Que similarly emphasized that you must acknowledge the thought behind a present rather than focus on whether the item matches your personal taste.

"When receiving a gift that may not particularly suit your taste, there is no need to express disappointment or allow your facial expression or body language to reveal your dislike, as doing so may unintentionally hurt the feelings of the person who thoughtfully chose it for you," she said.

"What deserves acknowledgment is not simply the gift itself, but the thought, time, and kindness behind the gesture," she continued.

Other do's and don'ts

Consider the recipient's age, gender, and lifestyle

Dayrit advised against giving sweets to senior citizens, particularly when they may have health conditions that could make such treats unsuitable.

Que also stressed the importance of considering the recipient's personality, interests, needs, and cultural sensitivities when choosing a gift.

"A meaningful gift need not be expensive; it simply needs to convey that the person was remembered and thoughtfully considered," she said.

Don't give food that is close to its expiration date

If you're giving edible gifts, make sure they can still be enjoyed well after Christmas. Food that can be properly stored or frozen may be a better option.

Follow the rules for group gift exchanges

If there is a set budget or theme, stick to it. Dayrit said that going overboard and giving something significantly more expensive than the agreed amount could make others feel uncomfortable.

Que likewise cautioned against unnecessarily extravagant gifts, which could potentially make a recipient feel uncomfortable.

"Gracious gift-giving is not about impressing someone, but about making them feel appreciated, respected, and genuinely thought of," she said.

Avoid overly personal gifts unless you know the recipient well

Dayrit also warned that religious items, personal hygiene products, underwear, self-help books, and the like may not be suitable to gift to someone you're not close to, as these may imply a person needs to change or improve something about themselves.

Don't give a gift that comes with unexpected responsibilities

These include pets and plants, as these require time and care.

Recycling a gift is acceptable, but do it carefully

Dayrit said a recycled gift can still be appropriate if the item is new, suitable for the new recipient, and thoughtfully presented.

Que, however, cautioned against thoughtless regifting, particularly within the same close circle of family or friends where the item may be recognized.

Pay attention to the condition of the packaging

Avoid giving presents in boxes or packaging that look like they have been sitting in storage for years.

Present your gift with care

According to Que, the way a gift is presented can also make a difference. Beautiful wrapping and a sincere note, she said, can make even the simplest gesture feel more special.