[ANALYSIS] Senator-judges hostile toward 'super witness' in VP Sara's trial
The long impeachment trial of Vice President Sara Duterte must have taken its toll on some senator-judges as they showed impatience over the testimony of the defense witness on Day 44.
Rainer Dela Fuente, a CPA-lawyer, took the witness stand the whole day in the hope of disputing prosecution witness Alex Cabrera’s forensic report and how AMLC executive director Ronel Buenaventura handled Duterte’s bank and financial records.
All these financial documents, said defense lawyer Mark Vinluan, were all part of a “fishing expedition” meant to smear and take Duterte out of the political landscape.
“We are only doing our job, as a lawyer, to ferret out the truth,” Vinluan said, justifying the presentation of Dela Fuente as an expert witness, with his credentials and own analysis seeking to match Cabrera’s. “There are two sides of the coin.”
Vinluan presented Dela Fuente as an expert witness to explain fundamental legal concepts under the Anti-Money Laundering Act and to argue that the methodology behind the alleged unexplained wealth findings against Duterte was "erroneous, malicious, and without merit.”
But upon the interjection of senator-judge Raffy Tulfo, Dela Fuente admitted he never had a copy of Cabrera’s forensic report, prompting a number of other senator-judges to criticize him, among them Tulfo’s brother Erwin, Risa Hontiveros, and Joel Villanueva.
Why? Because the report was confidential. “I practice what I preach; it is confidential,” the witness said. “I am not the intended user. I’d be happy to see it, but it is confidential. I am not the end user.”
Cabrera got his documents from the House, not from the Senate.
Dela Fuente echoed the defense line, detailing Cabrera’s shortcomings, including limited time and access to Duterte’s financial records. Two weeks to do a forensic report was very “challenging,” probably not enough to make a fair, complete conclusion.
It is “possible, but it's hard,” and “doable, but it's extremely hard.”
There are two types of anti-money laundering operations. Financial investigation is one. The other is financial analysis, which Cabrera did. What Cabrera did was “piercing, for analysis, case build-up, not evidence,” he said.
'Super witness'
Erwin told the defense panel that Dela Fuente and its other witnesses presented over the past few days had been “weak” and urged them to do better. “Baka mamaya 'pag tinanong ka, sasabihin mo wala kang alam.”
Dela Fuente was quite prepared for the interrogation.
With obvious sarcasm, Raffy described Dela Fuente's broad line of testimony, asking if the defense was presenting a "super witness" or "omni witness."
He called him a “super computer,” akin to an artificial intelligence app, ChatGPT, for “knowing” all the answers to all the questions.
“Anong bigat ng iyong opinyon kung wala ka palang nakitang report?” Kiko Pangilinan said.
Replied the witness: “Ang akin lang po, kung ano ang sinabi ng batas. Kung nabasa ko ang report, I will develop bias.”
Camille Villar and Imee Marcos defended Dela Fuente's credibility and capability to testify.
Villar said the court had accepted testimony from prosecution witness Cabrera even when some figures were sourced from the internet, arguing that Dela Fuente could similarly testify on universal financial principles without reviewing specific case documents.
Dela Fuente said that he did not need to read it because his testimony focuses on whether the methodologies align with the Anti-Money Laundering Act.
The defense witness also drew flak for saying that it was unlawful for AMLC to release Duterte’s financial records to a House committee in April 2025.
Only a competent court, he said, could order the release of the financial records.
Raffy questioned the necessity of calling Dela Fuente to testify on bank confidentiality. He said that the Senate had already settled this legal issue earlier in the trial, noting that impeachment courts are constitutionally exempt from bank secrecy restrictions when subpoenaing financial records.
Prosecution lawyer Chel Diokno said the release of the documents had been justified since these had been submitted to the impeachment court.
But Dela Fuente was talking about the release of the documents to the House, not to the impeachment court—something which Diokno kept on sidestepping. Only the courts or the authorized government offices can legally request and access confidential financial information from the AMLC, the witness said.
On the witness stand, Dela Fuente said the pieces of evidence gathered in violation of Duterte’s rights “were the fruits of a poisonous tree.”
Protecting the confidentiality and integrity of bank accounts was critical, he added, because banks served as the gateway to the financial system.
Diokno objected to qualifying Dela Fuente as an expert witness on money laundering, pointing out that the Articles of Impeachment did not actually charge Duterte with money laundering. Presiding officer Francis Escudero said that qualifying Dela Fuente as an expert simply allows him to offer his professional opinion, not that his statements are "gospel truth."
Like Diokno, Dela Fuente was mild-mannered. But the trial showed how parties in the trial could be haughty at times.
Next to the Tulfo brothers’ scathing remarks, Diokno openly described Dela Fuente as a “claimed expert” or a self-proclaimed expert. Vinluan described Cabrera as a “so-called” forensic expert.
Diokno wouldn’t want to be interrupted when he was talking, but he would regularly interrupt Vinluan, who kept on asking for “more leeway” from the court.
Diokno stopped short of calling Dela Fuente too juvenile to call himself an expert. He said the witness spent only 25 months as an AMLC finance investigator between July 2015 and August 2017, and that he was subsequently “taken out” of the agency’s compliance and investigation group.
It was too short a stint, the prosecution lawyer said.
But it was brief and meaningful, said the witness. “The experience wasn’t measured in quantity. If I didn’t have a good reputation, I would not have been given the accreditation in 2019, a year after I left.”
With an expressive face that gave away every thought, Diokno critiqued Dela Fuente, beginning with his work experience.
Dela Fuente has held various positions—11 months at the Bureau of Internal Revenue, 25 months at the AMLC, among others. A year after he left AMLC, he was accredited as an AMLC trainer.
Why didn’t Dela Fuente stay long in his jobs? "Bakit hindi ka nagtatagal sa trabaho?" Erwin told the witness about his short stints in different companies. “Hindi magandang tingnan.”
"'Yun hong mga dahilan ng aking pag-alis, it's beyond my control. I had to make hard choices," Dela Fuente said. He also stressed that despite his short tenures, he's able to maintain good relationships with his former colleagues to this day.
Had Duterte's name not been mentioned so many times, one would feel Dela Fuente was the one on trial.
Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not reflect the opinions of PhilSTAR L!fe, its parent company and affiliates, or its staff.