[ANALYSIS] Firm of VP Sara's husband a 'real' business, but questions remain
The defense panel in the impeachment trial of Vice President Sara Duterte presented two witnesses—one from the Department of Trade and Industry and another from the Food and Drug Administration—in the hope of shattering the prosecution’s claims that Cale88, a company once owned by her husband, was an “implausible” business model.
On Day 45, DTI Undersecretary Ceferino Rodolfo took the witness stand, and with the help of defense lawyer Justin Gular, presented a long list of pieces of documentary evidence showing Cale88 was anything but an implausible business.
Cale88 submitted its lone product, sweetened banana chips, to the FDA, which was duly approved, said the second witness, Director Pilar Marilyn Pagayunan of the FDA’s Center for Food Regulation and Research.
The defense dispensed with the testimony of a third witness, lawyer Eva Marie Mariquina of the Center for International Trade Expositions and Missions, who was supposed to authenticate email correspondence and official invitations showing Cale88 participated in international trade and food expositions.
Cale88 Foods Corporation was established as a small family-and-friends business selling homemade banana chips for domestic and export markets. It went through the process of registration and complied with legal requirements, including securing endorsement and certificates of good standing from the DTI since it was formed in September 2021.
The DTI approved the registration based on the required documents submitted, but it failed to make an actual inspection of the plant site because of the COVID-19 pandemic, until May 2026, when it made a surprise visit after the firm sought a certificate of good standing.
While the defense succeeded in asserting the legitimacy of Cale88, the prosecution failed to link the firm to its basic allegation—that it was an implausible firm, as claimed by prosecution witness, financial forensic analyst Atty. Alex Cabrera, and that it was a possible source of Duterte’s unexplained wealth.
Prosecution lawyer Erwin Matib harped and carped on Cale88’s registration, but he failed to zero in on Duterte’s alleged unexplained wealth, as pointed out by presiding officer Chiz Escudero. Matib even went to the extent of asking if Duterte had planted trees as part of the DTI requirement for a business registration.
Matib overlooked the fact that Duterte had no role in Cale88. That was ridiculous, to say the least. As ridiculous as the prosecution’s claims that it did not waste some three months presenting with gusto all conceivable witnesses on Articles I, III, and IV, only to withdraw all three before the defense could present counter-witnesses. People see what they only want to see.
What the prosecution overlooked, the Senate went into overdrive on Cale88’s funds, zeroing in on the P770 million it allegedly received from a state-owned Chinese firm, which some of them believed could have been money laundered.
But Rodolfo was not the right man to reinforce the allegations. He could only account for some P208 million, the accumulated sales of the firm for three years.
Up to that point, Rodolfo said he was ready to say the firm was above board, citing bank certificates or remittances for the transactions.
As to why the company suffered losses at one point, senator-judge Imee Marcos had to declare that the banana industry suffered a lot because of Panama disease, also called Fusarium wilt, a destructive soil-borne fungal disease. Because the fungus survived in soil for decades and resists chemical fungicides, it has caused major agricultural collapses and threatens global banana production.
But the other senator-judges also went too far, questioning Rodolfo beyond his area of competence. Risa Hontiveros asked about the P770 million, which was left hanging by the witnesses from AMLC and the banks. Joel Villanueva asked about the number of workers. Erwin Tulfo asked about financial scams. Others asked about the company’s incorporations. These were questions that could have been asked of other agencies, such as the AMLC, Department of Labor, and the Securities and Exchange Commission.
So many questions remain unsettled. It was obvious the trial still needed some more witnesses, more documents, more facts to ferret out the truth. Neither one had sufficiently answered all questions, so to speak.
Was Cale88 a legitimate business?
Right witness, wrong questions. Rodolfo didn’t come from DOLE, nor from SEC. The AMLC witness would come back to the witness stand.
“Ang sa amin lang po sa DTI ay operations,” said Rodolfo. “We are monitoring if the company has maintained 70% of its produce for export.”
Defense counsel Michael Poa promised on Day 44 that the panel would adequately address questions in the next hearing days. Without more witnesses, the prosecution had a field day claiming that none of the defense witnesses had sufficiently debunked claims of its own set of witnesses.
What the trial had was the forensic assessment Cabrera made that Duterte and her husband had amassed some P817.87 million in unexplained wealth, inaccurate SALN declarations, and failure to divest from business interests. This left many people questioning why the prosecution was banking on Cabrera’s “expert opinion” rather than hard facts.
While some defense witnesses were found wanting, some assertions raised by the prosecution were daunting, at first seemingly difficult, intimidating, or overwhelming in a way that made the witness feel uncomfortable.
Questions and answers evolved.
“Kailangan ba talagang i-declare sa DTI ang number of employees?” Gular asked Rodolfo. “Kailangan ba talagang matikman ninyo ang produkto?”
Before the Day 45 trial began, Erwin asked Escudero to order Duterte’s spokesman, lawyer Paolo Panelo, to explain his remarks accusing several senator-judges of bias and that he showed no respect for the impeachment court.
We did not wish to say if Panelo had disrespected the court. But whether the court was biased or not in whose favor was something else. Panelo was not alone. His critics have made similar allegations.
So far, given all the questions, whether the trial would end up acquitting or convicting Duterte seems not to be a legal question. The political side of the trial is too strong not to be noticed.
Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not reflect the opinions of PhilSTAR L!fe, its parent company and affiliates, or its staff.