SC increases civil damages for victims in crime cases
Victims of crimes in the Philippines may receive higher civil damages following a new Supreme Court ruling.
In a decision on Nov. 4 by Associate Justice Maria Filomena Singh, the SC En Banc approved updated guidelines concerning the award of civil indemnity ex delicto, moral damages, exemplary damages, and temperate damages in criminal cases.
The high court adopted monetary benchmarks that account for the "gravity of offenses, the harm suffered by victims and survivors, and changing economic realities."
"The value of judicial awards should not remain fixed when the financial and social circumstances underlying them have materially changed. Inflation, cost of living, wage growth, and fiscal stability are relevant considerations in determining appropriate awards," it explained.
However, the SC emphasized that adjusting damages should not simply mean calculating how much prices have gone up. It noted that the harm caused by crimes that violate a person's body, dignity, and freedom cannot be fully measured by money alone.
"These distinctions recognize the particular harm inflicted by sexual violence, especially when committed against children or by persons who exploit their relationship, authority, or position of trust," the SC said.
With this, courts may award higher damages depending on the circumstances of each case.
In a case where a six-year-old child became a victim of qualified rape, the amounts for civil indemnity, moral damages, and exemplary damages were each raised from P100,000 to P325,000.
For acts of lasciviousness, the corresponding amounts were each increased from P50,000 to P175,000.
The awards will earn 6% interest per year starting when the decision becomes final until the full amount is paid.
Higher compensation amounts were also set for crimes that result in death, as they recognized that the loss is "permanent and incapable of restoration." They distinguished between intentional killing and death caused by negligence, taking into account the greater responsibility involved when a person deliberately takes another person's life.
However, the SC clarified that this distinction does not mean the value of a human life differs depending on the manner of death.
"The Court underscored that civil damages are not merely incidental relief in criminal proceedings. They are essential expressions of the law’s recognition of the harm suffered by victims and society’s condemnation of criminal conduct. Through the updated guidelines, the Court seeks to ensure that monetary awards remain consistent, proportionate to the gravity of the offense, and responsive to the realities of victims," it said.
The SC said the updated amounts must be followed in all criminal cases moving forward.